Kevin JohnsonOlive oils have enhanced foods since ancient times. The first evidence of olive cultivation for oil production dates back to 4000 BC in the Middle East. Ancient communities harvested olives to produce ointments for ceremonial and medicinal purposes. They also used olive oil as lamp kerosene. In 2500 BC, the code of Hammurabi referred to the regulation of the buying and selling of oil products. Today’s home cooks, foodies, chefs, and culinary professionals value versatile oils. But which are the best olive oil brands? [1]
1. Cobram Estate
Cobram Estate is an Australian olive oil brand. It planted its first olive tree in 1998 and scaled its production, becoming one of the most sustainable extra-virgin olive oil (EVOO) producers. As of Dec 2024, Cobram Estate was the #8 olive oil brand in the competitive US market. It turns its by-products into viable, profitable product streams. Less than half of operational outputs from Cobram Estate’s olive groves and production end up in landfill. The brand won the AFR Sustainability Leader award in the Agriculture category in 2022, 2023, and 2024. Visit the Cobram Estate store on Amazon. [2]
Image source: Cobram Estate
Pros: Cobram Estate offers a wide range of high-quality, all-purpose extra virgin olive oils (EVOO). Its products are affordable. The brand combines olive varietals to create a balanced and robust flavor. For example, the award-winning Australia Select has Picual, Hojiblanca, and Coratina.
Cons: Cobram Estate isn’t the most budget-friendly olive oil brand.
Price Range: $12.99-$75
2. Graza
Graza is a cult-favorite olive oil brand and pantry staple founded in 2021 by Andrew Benin and Allen Dushi. The brand packs its Drizzle and Sizzle extra virgin finishing and cooking oils in chef-inspired squeeze bottles and nitrogen-sealed refill cans. It also offers Frizzle high-heat cooking oil made from olive pomace oil and EVOO. In Aug 2025, Graza introduced glass bottles for the Drizzle and Sizzle duo. You can buy Graza’s fresh, single-origin olive oil on Amazon, Whole Foods Market, and Kroger. Visit the Graza store on Amazon. [3]
Image source: Graza
Pros: Graza offers single-origin, single-varietal olive oils made from 100% olives. The brand highlights the harvest date on every bottle. It offers high-quality EVOO for cooking and finishing.
Cons: Graza only offers single-varietal olive oils. These oils may not meet the needs of home cooks and chefs seeking flavorful EVOOs with multiple varietals.
Price Range: $15-$42.99
3. Bono
Bono is a family-owned Italian olive oil brand founded in 1934 in Sciacca, Sicily. Its Sicily mill produces 5 tons of olive oil and 18,000 bottles per hour. The brand exports its products to Europe, the US, Canada, and Asia. In 2022, Bono collaborated with artist Alice Valenti to create new bottles honoring Sicily’s storied past. Its olive oils include the Sicily PGI, Val di Mazara DOP, Bono EVOO, Valle del Belice PDO, filtered and unfiltered Italian EVOO, and Ideo unfiltered EVOO. Visit the Bono store on Amazon. [4]
Image source: Bono
Pros: Bono embodies the ancient tradition of making olive oil. The brand only uses olives from the Val Di Mazara region to produce high-quality, phenol-rich, PDO-certified Sicilian oils, with notes of fresh grass and spice. Its verdant green oils hold up well to the high heat of a sauté pan or oven. Each Bono bottle has a unique serial number, ensuring traceability and authenticity.
Cons: Bono offers premium extra virgin olive oils. For example, the Val de Marza uses some of the world’s most coveted and superior olive varietals, including Biancolilla, Nocellara del Belice, and Cerasuola. This high-quality oil costs more than the market’s average.
Price Range: $21.50-$31.99
4. Iliada
Iliada is a Greek olive oil brand offering buttery EVOOs. The brand produces its oils from hand-picked indigenous Koroneiki olives grown in Kalamata. In 2025, the Iliada Kalamata PDO EVOO won the Gold Award at the NYIOOC World Olive Oil Competition. It was recognized as one of the best EVOOs in 2023 and earned a gold medal in 2024. Visit the Iliada store on Amazon. [5]
Image source: Iliada
Pros: Iliada offers rich, buttery Greek extra virgin olive oils. The brand prioritizes authentic origin and traditional production. Its olives are cold-extracted in the first 24 hours after picking, ensuring freshness.
Cons: Iliada olive oils cost more than the market’s average.
Price Range: $10-$69.99
5. California Olive Ranch
California Olive Ranch is an olive oil brand founded in 1998. The brand is the largest grower of olives for EVOO in California. It partners with farmers to produce oils, sauces, dressings, and vinegars. In May 2025, California Olive Ranch became the first EVOO retail brand to earn the Seed Oil Free Certified Seal. The company has several third-party certifications, including Certified Extra Virgin, Non-GMO Project Verified, USDA Organic, and Certified Regenerative. It has won over 260 awards at international tasting competitions. Visit the California Olive Ranch store on Amazon. [6]
Image source: California Olive Ranch
Pros: California Olive Ranch is a leading innovator in olive cultivation, harvesting, and milling. The brand offers award-winning, high-quality, and approachable olive oil. It has prioritized product quality, authenticity, and integrity for over 20 years.
Cons: California Olive Ranch’s high-end EVOOs can be pricey.
Price Range: $16.50-$175
6. Bertolli
Bertolli is an Italian olive oil brand owned by Deoleo. The brand offers budget-friendly oils. However, its history undermines consumer trust. In 2015, Italian authorities investigated Bertolli for selling low-quality oil as EVOO. Its parent company paid $7 million in a 2018 class-action lawsuit in the US for misusing the “Imported from Italy” label. The complainant sued Deoleo for using olives from Spain, Greece, and Tunisia. Deoleo agreed to include the origin of the olives in its label and improve product quality. Visit the Bertolli store on Amazon. [7]
Image source: Bertolli
Pros: Bertolli is a budget-friendly olive oil brand. It offers affordable EVOOs for everyday use.
Cons: Some consumers complain about the quality, aroma, and flavor of Bertolli olive oil. The brand blends regional olives, leading to inconsistencies. It isn’t the best option for consumers who value authenticity and transparency.
Price Range: $12.50-$28.99
7. Corto
Corto is a 100% California-grown olive oil brand. It is committed to culinary innovation, freshness, and flavor. In Sep 2025, Corto released its new Agrumato-Method Olive Oil Gift Set featuring the Calabrian Chili and Lemon Verbena olive oils. You can use Calabrian Chili for savory dishes and Lemon Verbena for sweet creations. Corto’s Chef Taste Panel created these new olive oils by cold-extracting freshly harvested olives with seasonal ingredients, resulting in vibrant, chef-caliber flavor. Visit the Corto store on Amazon. [8]
Image source: Corto
Pros: Corto offers award-winning oil varieties, including TRULY EVOO, limited-edition Agrumato-Method olive oil, La Padella Sauté Oil, and the Chef’s Essentials Kit. Consumers praise Corto’s TRULY olive oil for its smooth texture, light peppery finish, versatility, and fresh flavor with notes of hay and fruit.
Cons: Corto’s limited-edition Agrumato-Method olive oil is expensive. The set costs $80.
Price Range: $24.50-$80
8. Olivea
Olivea is an Azerbaijani olive oil brand offering ultra-high phenolic and premium organic options. The brand sources its olives from a 4,000-hectare farm owned by Grand Agro. It exports its products to Europe, North America, Russia, the UAE, and Israel. In Apr 2025, Olivea won three Gold Medals at international olive oil competitions in London, Canada, and Dubai. [9]
Image source: Olivea
Pros: Olivea is the go-to brand for health-conscious consumers seeking olive oils with high polyphenol content. It uses cold-press technology, without additives, to produce EVOOs with exquisite taste and health benefits. The brand is committed to product quality, transparent and sustainable production processes, and 100% natural composition.
Cons: Olivea’s olive oil has high-calorie and polyphenol content, increasing the risk of weight gain and digestive issues. Moderate your intake to avoid these risks.
Price Range: $24.95-$48.95
9. MANNI
MANNI is an Italian olive oil brand founded in 2000 by Armando Manni in Tuscany. “Our oil has an incredibly high concentration of antioxidant polyphenols, giving it a fragrant and intense flavor profile and a longer shelf life,” explained Armando Manni. In 2020, MANNI launched its first harvest with zero waste in its new Frantoio Manni mill in Tuscany. The world’s top chefs use and recommend MANNI’s EVOOs. MANNI Oil is “pure liquid gold,” said Gwyneth Paltrow. [10]
Image source: MANNI
Pros: MANNI offers ultra-fresh, high-quality olive oil with high antioxidant concentration and nutritional benefits. Its oil has a fragrant, rich, and peppery flavor profile and a long shelf life. The brand also prioritizes sustainability and purity.
Cons: MANNI is a premium olive oil brand. Its high-quality EVOOs are more expensive than standard olive oils. For example, MANNI’s Oil of Life costs $59.
Price Range: $20-$59
10. La Tourangelle
La Tourangelle is an olive oil brand founded in 2002. Its California mill produces oils using 150-year-old French methods and ships the product in lightweight tin cans to retailers and consumers. In 2021, La Tourangelle planted 10,000 olive trees at its Woodland orchard. It launched a California-grown olive oil in 2024. Visit the La Tourangelle store on Amazon. [11]
Image source: La Tourangelle
Pros: La Tourangelle offers versatile, single-origin, cold-pressed EVOOs. This sustainable brand uses recyclable tins to minimize light degradation and oxidation, preserving quality and freshness. Its EVOOs have a rich flavor with peppery or fruity notes.
Cons: La Tourangelle is the best option for walnut and grapeseed oils rather than extra-virgin olive oil. The brand only started producing its California-grown olive oil in 2024.
Price Range: $15.99-$45.99
11. Carapelli
Carapelli is a Deoleo subsidiary specializing in olive oil. It offers premium but reasonably priced oils for cooking and dipping. In 2024, Carapelli was sued for importing olive oil through a Swiss subsidiary and rebottling the oil in Italy for export outside the European Union (EU). These legal issues eroded Carapelli’s parent company’s profitability, leading to a $59.1 million loss in 2024. However, Deoleo’s annual revenue increased by 19% in 2024 to $1.08 billion. Visit the Carapelli store on Amazon. [12]
Image source: Carapelli
Pros: Carapelli offers affordable, versatile olive oil for everyday cooking, salads, and dipping bread. The brand partners with a master Oliari to determine the optimum olive ripening and harvesting time. This process enhances the oil’s organoleptic and nutritional properties. Its extra virgin olive oil has a grassy aroma, a well-balanced buttery flavor, and a fruity, peppery finish. [13]
Cons: Some customers complain about Carapelli’s flavor and quality inconsistency. Its ongoing legal issues undermine consumer trust and confidence in the brand.
Price Range: $10.30-$24
12. Frankies 457
Frankies 457 is an Italian brand offering handcrafted olive oils and pastas. Its olives are harvested, cold-pressed, and packaged in Sicily, ensuring consistency and a vibrant flavor. You can use the Frankies 457 Organice EVOO on bread or as the base for spaghetti aglio e olio. Visit the Frankies 457 store on Amazon. [14]
Image source: Frankies 457
Pros: Frankies 457 offers versatile, fresh-tasting, all-purpose extra virgin olive oil. Pair the oil with bread or aglio e olio pasta to experience its rich flavor.
Cons: Frankies 457 is a premium olive oil brand. It may not be the best choice for everyday usage and budget-conscious consumers.
Price Range: $28-$35
References & more information
- FS Staff (2025, Jan 20). Olive oil: a history spanning thousands of years. Frantoio Sant’amico
- DLA Piper (2024, Dec 18). Making business better with Cobram Estate. DLAPipper.com
- Graza (2025, Aug 7). Graza goes glass: Leading olive oil brand expands format offerings for Drizzle and Sizzle. PRNewswire
- Fitzgerald, A. (2022, Feb 18). Family Owned Sicilian Olive Oil Brand, Bono, Is Poised To Become Your New Favorite. Forbes
- SV Staff (2025, May 15). Greek olive oil Iliada won a gold medal at a prestigious world competition! Super Vero
- California Olive Ranch (2025, May 27). Radical Transparency Bears Fruit: California Olive Ranch Earns Seed Oil Free Certification. Business Wire
- OFM Staff (2025, May 15). Is Bertolli Olive Oil Any Good? A Critical Look at Quality and Origin. Olij Folie Market
- Corto Olive Oil (2025, Sep 3). Corto Launches Limited-Edition Agrumato-Method Olive Oil Gift Set: Calabrian Chili for Savory & Lemon Verbena for Sweet. Globe Newswire
- SFFF (2025, Apr 1). “Olivea Extra Virgin Olive Oil” from Azerbaijan Achieves New International Triumph! Specialty and Fine-Food Fairs
- McKenzie, L. (2025, May 27). The posh olive oil revolution. The Times
- Pedrosa, C. (2025, Jul 11). From France to Woodland, a family cooking oil business La Tourangelle takes root. SAC Bee
- OFI Staff (2025, Mar 26). World’s largest olive oil bottler reports €54.5M loss for 2024. OFI Magazine
- Carapelli (2024, Jan 15). Why is Carapelli one of the most renowned olive oil brands in the world? Carapelli.com
- Rohlinger, K. (2024, Feb 24). I made Spaghetti Aglio e Olio with the Olive Oil used in “The Bear.” Pop Sugar
- Featured image by Juan Gomez
Tell us what you think? Did you find this article interesting? Share your thoughts and experiences in the comments section below.
Add comment